A New Grammar of the English Tongue - Practical Grammar

In this review of A New Grammar of the English Tongue, the reviewer evaluates an 1898 instructional volume republished to serve students and enthusiasts of classical English grammar. The bottom line: this work is best for readers who want a traditional, comprehensive study of etymology, syntax and sentence construction, and who appreciate historical, methodical explanations rather than modern pedagogy. The single biggest reason to buy is its thorough coverage of composition and punctuation drawn from an earlier era of instruction, making it a valuable reference for serious study or comparative language research.

Key Features

• Comprehensive grammar: The book covers etymology, syntax and sentence structure to give readers a broad, classical foundation in English grammar.
• Chapters on composition: Practical advice on composition supports readers in writing clearer, better-structured prose.
• Versification material: Discussion of versification helps those studying poetic form and rhythm to understand technical aspects of English verse.
• Paraphrasing and punctuation: Focused chapters on paraphrasing and punctuation provide practical guidance for editing and refining sentences.
• Historical perspective: Originally published in 1898, the work offers insight into period teaching methods and the evolution of grammar instruction.

Who It's For

This edition is for students, teachers and language historians who want a methodical, classical grammar text that emphasizes structure and traditional rules. It suits readers preparing for detailed study of syntax, composition, or those comparing past and present approaches to teaching English.

Readers seeking a modern, communicative approach to grammar instruction, contemporary usage notes or up-to-date examples should look elsewhere; this book reflects an older pedagogical style rather than current classroom methods.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Thorough treatment of grammar topics gives a complete reference for etymology and syntax study.
• Dedicated sections on composition and punctuation make it useful for improving written expression.
• Historical text provides perspective on late 19th-century grammar instruction and terminology.

Cons

• Language, examples and pedagogy reflect its 1898 origin and may feel dated to readers expecting modern usage guidance.

Specifications

Title	A New Grammar of the English Tongue
Author / Brand	J. M. Meiklejohn
Original publication	1898
Content focus	Etymology, syntax, sentence structure, composition, versification, punctuation
Type	Reference grammar book
Use case	Study, reference, historical comparison

Our Verdict

For serious students and teachers who value a traditional, systematic approach to English grammar, this reprint of Meiklejohn's work is a worthwhile reference that delivers detailed coverage of composition, punctuation and versification. It is good value for those seeking historical depth and structured lessons, though readers wanting modern usage updates should supplement it with contemporary resources.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this an original 1898 edition?
This is a republication of the original 1898 work, presented as a reprint for contemporary readers.

What topics does the book cover?
It covers etymology, syntax, sentence structure, composition, versification, paraphrasing and punctuation.

Who should avoid this book?
Readers seeking a modern, communicative grammar guide with current usage examples should consider a contemporary text instead.