Allstare Griddle Plate 19.7 x 7.9 in - Heavy Matte Enamel Cast Iron

Our review of the Allstare griddle plate finds it best suited to anyone who needs a durable, flat-top cooking surface that replaces factory stove griddles. The single biggest reason to buy is its heavier matte enamel cast iron construction, which resists warping and offers long-term durability compared with thin porcelain or cast aluminum alternatives. For cooks who want a stable, even-heating pan for pancakes, eggs, grilled sandwiches and tortillas, this griddle is a straightforward replacement part that fits many Whirlpool, Jenn-Air, Maytag, KitchenAid and Kenmore ranges.

Key Features

• Material: Matte enamel cast iron provides a sturdy, long-lasting surface that tolerates high heat without warping.
• Dimensions: The 19.7 x 7.9 in size gives a broad flat area that fits the middle burner on many compatible gas ranges and holds multiple pancakes or eggs.
• Compatibility: Manufactured to match OEM numbers like W10432544 and W10432539 so it can replace original griddle plates on supported models.
• Even heating: Cast iron holds and distributes heat consistently for better browning and less hot-spot cooking when preheated properly.
• Seasoning guidance: The included seasoning approach makes the surface effectively non-stick after repeated oiling and heating cycles.
• Safety design: Raised ridges and a flat profile help contain oil while offering gripping points for safer handling.

Who It's For

This griddle is aimed at home cooks and technicians who need a direct replacement for the flat top griddle found on select Whirlpool, Jenn-Air, Maytag and KitchenAid gas ranges. It is particularly useful for anyone who prefers cast iron for its sturdiness and multi-surface use, including stovetop, oven or outdoor cooking.

It is less suitable for buyers who need a lightweight or truly non-stick surface out of the box; cast iron is heavy and requires proper seasoning to reduce stickiness, and those who prefer low-maintenance coated pans may want to look elsewhere.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Solid build quality from matte enamel cast iron that resists warping under high heat.
• Good fit for many OEM griddle replacements, so installation is straightforward on compatible ranges.
• Versatile use across stovetop, oven or grill thanks to cast iron strength.
• When properly seasoned, yields a mostly non-stick cooking surface for delicate foods.

Cons

• Heavy weight can make handling and placement awkward for some users.
• Surface sticks until it has been fully seasoned and maintained per instructions.

Specifications

Brand	Allstare
Material	Matte enamel cast iron
Pack	1 Pack
Dimensions	19.7 in x 7.9 in
Compatible OEM Numbers	W10432544, W10432539 and similar
Compatible Ranges	Selected Whirlpool, Jenn-Air, Maytag, KitchenAid, Kenmore models

Our Verdict

The Allstare 19.7 x 7.9 in matte enamel cast iron griddle is a practical replacement for people who need a heavy-duty flat griddle that matches OEM parts and holds heat well. It offers solid value for anyone willing to accept the extra weight and to season the surface; once broken in it performs reliably for pancakes, eggs and grilled sandwiches on compatible ranges.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will this griddle fit my stove?
Check the original part dimensions and OEM numbers like W10432544 or W10432539 before ordering to confirm compatibility with your model.

Is the surface non-stick right away?
No, the matte enamel cast iron requires seasoning as described in the instructions to build up a non-stick surface over several cycles.

Can it be used on outdoor grills or in the oven?
Yes, cast iron is versatile and designed to withstand high heat, making it usable on stovetops, in ovens and on many grills.