Amish Pie Filling No Sugar Added Cherry - Two 32 Oz Jars

In this review the reviewer finds the Amish Pie Filling No Sugar Added Cherry best for home bakers who want a convenient, fruit-forward filling without added sugar. The biggest reason to buy is its simple, natural ingredient list and ready-to-use format that cuts prep time; opening a jar and filling a crust replaces peeling and simmering fruit while still delivering a real cherry flavor sweetened by grape juice concentrate. For anyone who values convenience and cleaner ingredients, this pie filling is a practical pantry staple.

Key Features

• No sugar added: Uses grape juice concentrate and natural fruit juices for sweetness, offering a lower-added-sugar option for baking and toppings.
• Ready to use: Comes fully prepared in a glass jar so you can fill a crust or spoon over desserts without additional cooking or sweetening.
• Real fruit content: Made from cherries as the primary ingredient, providing authentic cherry flavor rather than an artificial syrup.
• Glass packaging: Packaged in 32 oz glass jars that preserve flavor and make it easy to see contents and store leftovers.
• Family recipe heritage: Produced by a long-running artisan maker with a history of small-batch pie fillings and toppings, which tends to emphasize quality ingredients.

Who It's For

This product is ideal for home bakers who want a quick way to make cherry pies or to top desserts without added table sugar, and for households seeking a filling that leans on real fruit and simple ingredients. It suits people who appreciate a pudding-like, consistent texture that spreads easily into a pie shell and slices cleanly after baking.

It is less appropriate for bakers who insist on very high fruit-to-syrup ratios or who prefer making fillings from fresh, hand-chopped fruit. Also, those avoiding grape juice or any concentrated juice as a sweetener should check ingredients closely before buying.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Clean ingredient list with no added sugar, relying on fruit juices for sweetness.
• Convenient 32 oz glass jars that are ready to use and easy to store.
• Good cherry flavor and a pudding-like consistency that many customers prefer to canned options.

Cons

• Some customers report modest fruit content compared with homemade fillings, so those wanting large fruit pieces may be disappointed.

Specifications

Product	Amish Pie Filling No Sugar Added Cherry
Pack size	Two 32 oz jars
Primary ingredients	Cherries, grape juice concentrate, water, modified food starch, almond flavoring
Sweetener	Grape juice concentrate (no added cane sugar)
Packaging	Glass jar
Made in	USA

Our Verdict

For bakers who want a no-sugar-added, ready-made cherry filling that saves time and uses simple ingredients, this two-jar pack is a sensible buy. It delivers authentic cherry flavor and a stable, easy-to-handle consistency that works well in pies and as a topping, though those seeking very high fruit chunkiness may prefer a homemade option.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this filling truly without added sugar?
Yes, no refined sugar is added; sweetness comes from grape juice concentrate and the fruit itself.

Can it be used straight from the jar in a pie?
Yes, the filling is ready to use and can be poured into a crust and baked according to your recipe.

How many pies will two 32 oz jars make?
Each 32 oz jar typically fills one standard 9-in pie, so this two-jar pack should cover two pies or multiple smaller desserts.