Caraway Nonstick 9 x 6.5 Small Rectangle Baking Pan - Safe Ceramic

Our review of the Caraway Nonstick 9 x 6.5 Small Rectangle Baking Pan finds it best for cooks who need a compact, reliable pan for small batches and tight ovens; the single biggest reason to buy is its genuinely non-toxic ceramic coating that delivers easy release without PFAS, PFOA, or Teflon. The pan balances thoughtful construction and everyday usefulness: it is deep enough for small casseroles or portioned lasagna, heats evenly for brownies and roasted vegetables, and cleans up with minimal effort. For small kitchens or anyone who values a safer nonstick surface, this pan performs as promised.

Key Features

• Non-toxic ceramic coating: A naturally slick surface frees food easily and avoids chemical-laden coatings for healthier baking.
• Compact deep design: The 9 x 6.5 size and deeper sides make it ideal for small batches like single-serve casseroles and portioned lasagna.
• Aluminized steel core: Reinforced construction delivers durability and resists warping under regular oven use up to high temperatures.
• Oven safe to 550F: High heat tolerance means it can handle roasting and baking tasks that require sustained temperatures.
• Easy release and cleanup: Rounded edges and the slick surface let food slide out and reduce scrubbing after use.
• Space-saving: A compact form fits smaller ovens and kitchens while still offering premium bakeware performance.

Who It's For

The pan is a good fit for home cooks who prepare smaller portions, live in apartments with compact ovens, or maintain a small household and want a dependable pan for casseroles, brownies, vegetables, and lasagna portions. It also appeals to shoppers focused on safer cookware surfaces, since the ceramic coating is free of PFAS, PFOA, and Teflon.

Those who regularly bake very large casseroles or sheet cakes should look for larger rectangular pans, and users who need cookware for stovetop searing or broiler-only tasks may prefer different materials that tolerate direct flame or aggressive high-heat surface contact.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Truly non-stick ceramic surface that lets foods release cleanly and cuts cleanup time.
• Compact but deep profile makes it versatile for small casseroles, roasted veg, and brownies.
• Sturdy aluminized steel core and reinforced rims reduce the risk of warping and improve durability.

Cons

• Smaller capacity means it is not suitable for large family-sized casseroles.
• Some buyers find the price higher than basic steel pans, though others report the build and finish justify it.

Specifications

Our Verdict

The Caraway 9 x 6.5 small rectangle baking pan is a smart choice for cooks who need a compact, durable pan with a safer non-toxic ceramic surface and reliable nonstick performance. It is worth buying if you bake small batches often and want a pan that heats evenly, cleans quickly, and resists warping in smaller ovens.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the coating free of common nonstick chemicals?
Yes, the ceramic coating is promoted as free from PFAS, PFOA, and Teflon for a toxin-free surface.

Can this pan go in a hot oven?
Yes, the pan is oven safe up to 550F thanks to its aluminized steel core and reinforced rims.

Will food stick to the pan?
Most users report easy release and quick cleanup because of the naturally slick ceramic surface, though proper preheating and gentle use will extend the coating life.