Caraway Nonstick 9 x 6.5 Small Rectangle Baking Pan - Sage

In this review of the Caraway Nonstick 9 x 6.5 Small Rectangle Baking Pan, the bottom line is straightforward: this pan is for cooks who need a compact, dependable pan for small batches without toxic coatings. The reviewer found it especially useful for single-serve casseroles, brownie portions and roasted vegetables in smaller ovens, where even heat and effortless release matter. If you want safer bakeware with a naturally slick surface free of PFAS, PFOA and Teflon, this pan delivers on that primary promise while remaining durable and easy to clean.

Key Features

• Non-toxic ceramic coating: The naturally slick ceramic surface provides release without PFAS, PFOA or Teflon, which makes cleanup quicker and reduces worry about chemical exposure.
• Compact deep design: At 9 x 6.5 in size, this rectangular pan is sized for small batches and fits comfortably in compact ovens and kitchens without sacrificing depth for casseroles or lasagna portions.
• Aluminized steel core: A reinforced core and rims give the pan rigidity and resistance to warping, so it holds its shape under regular oven use up to high temperatures.
• Oven safe to 550F: The construction withstands high heat, allowing roasting, baking, and broiling tasks that require higher temperatures.
• Easy release and cleanup: Rounded edges and the slick coating help food slide out and make hand washing quick with minimal residue.

Who It's For

The pan is best for people with smaller households, apartment cooks, or anyone who frequently prepares side dishes, single-serve casseroles, or portioned desserts. It also suits cooks who prioritize safer surface coatings and simple cleanup over managing large batches.

Those who regularly bake full-size lasagnas, large sheet cakes, or need a full set of commercial-size pans should look elsewhere, as this pan is intentionally compact and tailored to smaller quantities rather than large-scale baking.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Truly non-stick ceramic surface makes release and cleanup noticeably easier than standard metal pans.
• Solid aluminized steel core and reinforced rims reduce warping and feel durable in use.
• Deep, compact dimensions are ideal for small ovens and batch cooking without wasting space.
• Attractive sage finish that customers report liking for looks as well as function.

Cons

• Smaller size means it is not suitable for full-size family roasts or large sheet-batch baking.
• Some buyers question value relative to price even though performance and build are strong.

Specifications

Brand	Caraway
Size	9 x 6.5 in
Coating	Non-toxic ceramic (PFAS, PFOA, Teflon free)
Core material	Aluminized steel
Oven safe temperature	Up to 550F
Design	Deep rectangular baking pan with reinforced rims

Our Verdict

For cooks who need a reliable small baking pan that prioritizes a toxin-free surface and easy cleanup, this Caraway small rectangle pan is a strong choice. It pairs non-stick ceramic coating with a sturdy aluminized steel core, making it a durable option for everyday small-batch baking, roasting and portioned desserts while saving space in compact kitchens.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this pan truly non-stick?
Yes. The ceramic coating is naturally slick and customers report easy release for items like roasted vegetables and small meats.

Can it go in a high-temperature oven?
Yes. The pan is rated oven safe up to 550F thanks to its aluminized steel core and reinforced rims.

Is this pan large enough for a family-sized lasagna?
No. The 9 x 6.5 in size is intended for small batches and portions rather than a full family-size lasagna.