Chicago Metallic 17in x 12.25in Non-Stick Cookie and Jelly-Roll Pan

In this review of the Chicago Metallic 17in x 12.25in baking sheet set, the bottom line is simple: this is a hardworking, space-saving set for home bakers who want reliable heat distribution and easy release. The set includes two heavy-weight carbon steel sheets and a matching cooling rack, and it stands out for consistent browning and the convenience of a non-stick coating that speeds cleanup. For anyone who regularly bakes cookies, bars, jelly rolls or one-pan meals, this set delivers practical performance without fuss.

Key Features

• Heavy-weight carbon steel: Provides even heat distribution so cookies and sheet-pan meals bake uniformly without hot spots.
• Non-stick coating: Helps baked goods release cleanly and reduces scrubbing time during cleanup.
• Wire rod reinforced rim: Prevents warping under high temperatures, keeping pans flat for consistent contact with the oven rack.
• Included cooling rack: Lets you finish cookies and pastries properly while using the pan for the next batch.
• Perfect size: Inner dimensions of 17in x 12.25in fit standard oven racks and offer room for multiple cookies or a jelly roll.
• Stackable storage: Thin profile and compatible shape make the pans easy to stack with other bakeware for space saving.

Who It's For

This set is best for home bakers who make cookies, bars, jelly rolls, roasted vegetables or sheet-pan dinners and want consistent results without specialized equipment. The pans are well suited to kitchens where oven space is standard and storage is at a premium, thanks to stackable design and included cooling rack.

Professional bakers who need larger commercial pans or heavy-duty, reinforced sheet trays for daily high-volume use might prefer thicker commercial-grade steel. Also, if a user requires specialized non-stick coatings rated for metal utensils, they should verify care instructions before use.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Even heat distribution from heavy-weight carbon steel delivers consistent baking results.
• Non-stick surface on both pans and the cooling rack makes release and cleaning easier.
• Wire rod reinforced rim resists warping, maintaining a flat surface for even contact.
• Includes a cooling rack and two pans, offering versatility for multiple batches and recipes.

Cons

• Non-stick coating requires careful handling and cleaning to preserve performance over time.
• Not marketed as commercial-grade, so extremely high-volume users may prefer heavier-duty options.

Specifications

Brand	Chicago Metallic
Material	Heavy-weight carbon steel
Pan outer size	17.75in x 13in x 1in
Pan inner size	17in x 12.25in x 1in
Cooling rack size	16.75in x 11.5in
Finish	Non-stick coating
Rim	Wire rod reinforced rim to resist warping

Our Verdict

The Chicago Metallic 17in x 12.25in non-stick pan set is a practical, good-value choice for home bakers who want even baking, easy release and space-saving storage. With two pans plus a cooling rack and a reinforced rim to prevent warp, it covers the needs of most household baking without unnecessary extras.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these pans oven safe for high temperatures?
Yes, the heavy-weight carbon steel pans are suitable for standard oven types and the reinforced rim helps maintain shape at typical baking temperatures.

Does the cooling rack have a non-stick finish?
Yes, the cooling rack features the same non-stick coating as the pans for easier release and cleaning.

Will these stack for storage?
Yes, the pans are designed to be stackable and can nest within other baking sheets to save cupboard space.