ColorKing Compatible 58A CF258A Toner Cartridge 2-Pack - With Chip

In this review of the ColorKing compatible 58A CF258A toner 2-pack, the bottom line is simple: small offices and home users who need reliable monochrome printing at a low cost will appreciate these cartridges. The reviewer found the biggest reason to buy is the included chip, which removes a common installation step and lets the cartridges work with HP LaserJet Pro M404 and MFP M428 series printers without manual modification. Setup may trigger a first-install message, but it does not affect print quality or printer safety.

Key Features

• With chip included: Each cartridge comes equipped with a recycled original chip so installation requires no chip removal and prints immediately after acknowledging initial prompts.
• High page yield: Each CF258A cartridge is rated for about 3,000 pages at 5% coverage, giving a combined yield of roughly 6,000 pages for the two-pack.
• Broad compatibility: Works with HP LaserJet Pro M404, M404n, M404dn, M404dw and MFP M428fdw, M428fdn, M428dw models for straightforward replacement.
• Stable output quality: Designed to deliver sharp text and crisp images with no streaking or leakage in routine office printing tasks.
• Recycled chip warning guidance: The product notes that printer prompts about used or counterfeit cartridges are expected on first install and can be dismissed without harming the printer.

Who It's For

These cartridges suit small business owners, home office users, and anyone who runs a compatible HP LaserJet Pro M404 or MFP M428 printer and wants a cost-effective alternative to OEM toner. The included chip streamlines installation for users who prefer a plug-and-play replacement and expect standard monochrome document work rather than photo printing.

Users who require manufacturer-branded consumables for managed print environments, strict warranty concerns, or integrated fleet tracking may prefer OEM cartridges instead. Also, extreme high-volume sites that need extended-yield 58X specifications should confirm compatibility and yield expectations before choosing the standard 58A option.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Included chip makes install faster and prevents the need for manual chip removal.
• Good combined page yield of about 6,000 pages for the two-pack at 5% coverage.
• Delivers consistent text sharpness and stable prints without noticeable streaking or leakage.

Cons

• First installation may trigger used or counterfeit cartridge messages that must be dismissed, which could concern some users.

Specifications

Brand	ColorKing compatible
Model / Part	58A CF258A (compatible), two-pack
With chip	Yes, recycled original chip installed
Page yield	Approximately 3,000 pages per cartridge at 5% coverage
Compatible printers	HP LaserJet Pro M404 series, MFP M428 series, Enterprise M406dn, MFP M430f
Package contents	Two compatible black toner cartridges (not OEM)

Our Verdict

The ColorKing compatible 58A CF258A 2-pack is a practical, value-oriented replacement for users of supported HP LaserJet Pro and MFP printers who want simple installation and reliable monochrome output. It offers good page yield and consistent text quality, making it a sensible choice for small offices and home users seeking savings without sacrificing day-to-day performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the printer accept the cartridge if it shows a counterfeit message?
Yes; the review notes the first installation can prompt Used or counterfeit warnings, which can be dismissed and will not harm the printer or affect printing.

Do these cartridges require removing a chip before installation?
No; these ColorKing replacements come equipped with a recycled original chip so no chip removal is necessary.

Are these OEM cartridges?
No; the product is a high-performance compatible replacement and is not an original manufacturer cartridge.