Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boots - Waterproof Mid-Calf Fit

In this review of the Columbia Women's Ice Maiden II Snow Boots the bottom line is simple: these are a practical, warm and waterproof mid-calf boot for cold winter days. The standout reason to buy is dependable protection from wet, snowy conditions thanks to the waterproof leather upper and seam-sealed membrane bootie construction, combined with 200g insulation that keeps toes warm on subzero days. The review focuses on real-world comfort, traction, and how the boot balances style and function for everyday winter use.

Key Features

• Waterproof leather upper: Keeps feet dry during snow and slush with seem-sealed membrane bootie construction that prevents water seepage.
• TECHLITE midsole: Provides lightweight cushioning and high energy return for comfortable all-day walking in winter conditions.
• Omni-GRIP outsole: Non-marking rubber traction designed for reliable grip on icy sidewalks and snowy parking lots.
• 200g insulation: Offers cozy warmth rated for cold days down to -25F/-32C to handle heavy snow and low temperatures.
• Quilted ankle support and faux fur collar: Blends a feminine look with support and a soft collar that adds comfort and covers the ankle.
• Reinforced toe and heel: Leather reinforcement at high-wear areas increases durability for regular winter use.

Who It's For

The Ice Maiden II is aimed at women who need a reliable winter boot for daily use in snowy or slushy climates, including commuters, dog walkers, and anyone who spends time outdoors in New England or similar winters. It is especially useful for those who want a balance of warmth, waterproof protection, and moderate cushioning without a bulky mountaineering style.

Those who should look elsewhere include people who need a lightweight running shoe for winter trail running, or those seeking extreme mountaineering boots with technical crampon compatibility. Also, buyers who prefer a very narrow or very wide last may want to try on different models first because sizing opinions vary among customers.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Warm 200g insulation and faux fur collar provide notable warmth and winter comfort.
• Waterproof leather and seem-sealed membrane keep feet dry in snow and slush.
• TECHLITE midsole delivers comfortable cushioning and good energy return for walking.
• Omni-GRIP outsole offers dependable traction while remaining non-marking for indoor wear.

Cons

• Sizing can be inconsistent between customers, so trying on with thick socks is recommended.
• As a mid-calf lifestyle boot, it lacks the stiffness or ankle lock some technical winter activities require.

Specifications

Our Verdict

The Columbia Ice Maiden II is a solid choice for women who want a waterproof, warm and comfortable winter boot that wears well around town. It delivers good traction, long-lasting cushioning, and durable materials at a sensible value for everyday winter use; just check fit with the socks you plan to wear.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these boots waterproof?
Yes, the boots use a waterproof leather upper and a seem-sealed membrane bootie design to prevent water from entering.

Will they be warm enough for very cold weather?
They have 200g insulation and are temperature rated to about -25F/-32C, suitable for heavy snow and very cold days in most winter climates.

Do they run true to size?
Customer feedback is mixed on sizing; some find them true to size while others suggest ordering a half size down or trying them on with thick socks before deciding.