Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Topwater Fishing Lure - Big Fish Action

In this review the Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper is evaluated for anglers chasing large saltwater and freshwater predators. The bottom line: this is a purpose-built topwater bait for targeting big fish thanks to its large 6 and 7 in sizes and a weighted tail that delivers long casts and strong surface action. For anyone who fishes for stripers, redfish, musky or large bass and wants a durable plug that performs well with the classic Walk the Dog technique, this lure is a solid, reliable choice.

Key Features

• Large fishing sizes: Available in 6 in and 7 in options, the lure presents a sizable profile that draws attention from larger predators and improves catchability.
• Weighted tail: Weight concentrated at the tail end produces potent action on the surface and helps anglers achieve longer, more controlled casts.
• Versatile bait: Originally designed for striped bass, it also works effectively on other big gamefish such as redfish, musky and large bass.
• Tough and durable construction: Built to withstand strikes and hard fights, the plug holds up to repeated use against strong species and rough conditions.
• Walk the Dog technique: Specifically suited to the walk the dog retrieve, the lure creates lifelike side-to-side action that provokes surface strikes.

Who It's For

This lure is aimed at saltwater and freshwater anglers who target larger predators and want a classic topwater option with proven surface action. Boat anglers and surf casters who need extra casting distance will appreciate the weighted tail and the larger 6 in and 7 in profiles for enticing big fish.

It may be less suitable for small-pond panfish anglers or those who prefer subsurface plugs and jigs; likewise, anglers who want replaceable terminal tackle options might note differing opinions about hook quality and consider swapping hooks if desired.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Large profile and strong surface action make it effective for big gamefish and stripers.
• Weighted tail improves casting distance and delivers powerful tail-driven action.
• Durable build and strong treble hooks provide good value and hold up under heavy use.

Cons

• Some anglers report mixed opinions on the stock hook quality, so hook replacement may be considered.

Specifications

Brand	Cotton Cordell
Model	Pencil Popper
Available sizes	6 in, 7 in
Design	Topwater pencil popper with weighted tail
Target species	Striped bass, bass, musky, redfish and other big fish
Technique	Walk the Dog surface retrieve

Our Verdict

The Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper is a dependable topwater lure for anglers pursuing bigger predators; its large sizes and weighted tail give it compelling surface action and casting range. For those who value a classic striper bait that is tough and catchable, it delivers good value, though swapping hooks is a simple upgrade for picky anglers.

Frequently Asked Questions

What sizes does the Pencil Popper come in?
The lure is offered in 6 in and 7 in sizes suitable for larger gamefish.

Can it handle hard-fighting species?
Yes, the plug is built tough for species such as stripers, musky, redfish and large bass.

Is the lure good for long casts?
Yes, the weighted tail helps increase casting distance while maintaining strong surface action.