Air Fryer Tray Replacement for Cuisinart TOA-28 & AFR-25 - Mesh Steel

In this review of the Air Fryer Tray Replacement for Cuisinart TOA-28 and AFR-25, the bottom line is simple: this mesh steel basket is a practical, durable replacement for users who want reliable air circulation and easier cleanup. The reviewer found it especially useful for households that cook fries, chicken wings, or roasted vegetables frequently, because the open mesh design promotes 360 heat circulation and the food-grade steel construction resists warping when used properly after preheating.

Key Features

• Precise Fit: Sized at 10.7 in x 9.8 in x 2.1 in to fit Cuisinart TOA-28 and AFR-25 models, providing a direct replacement without modification.
• Food Grade Steel: Constructed from food grade steel that is non-toxic and tasteless, meeting FDA-oriented standards for safer cooking.
• Non-stick Mesh Design: The fine wire mesh lifts food above the tray to improve airflow and crisping for fries, wings, and roasted vegetables.
• Dishwasher Safe: The basket cleans up easily in the dishwasher and is less fussy to maintain than some original factory trays.
• High Temperature Resistance: Rated to withstand heat up to 480F, with a recommended preheat step to avoid deformation and maximize lifespan.
• Versatile Cooking: Suitable for grilling, baking and air frying a wide range of foods from vegetables to small cuts of meat.

Who It's For

This basket is best for owners of Cuisinart TOA-28 or AFR-25 toaster air fryer ovens who need a straightforward replacement part that restores airflow and crisping performance. It also suits cooks who value easy cleanup and metal durability over coated or flimsy trays.

Those who should look elsewhere include owners of air fryers with different internal dimensions and users who prefer trays with solid non-mesh surfaces for very small or loose foods that might fall through; in those cases a different accessory or a pan insert would be a better match.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Durable food grade steel construction that resists chemicals and off-flavors.
• Mesh design promotes even air circulation and crisping of foods like fries and wings.
• Dishwasher friendly and cleans more easily than some original trays according to customers.
• Fits Cuisinart TOA-28 and AFR-25 models and compatible ovens of similar size.

Cons

• Requires a preheat step (300F for 10 minutes) to avoid deformation, which adds one extra step before first use.
• Mesh surface may not suit very small items unless used with a tray or liner underneath.

Specifications

Compatible Models	Cuisinart TOA-28, AFR-25 and similarly sized ovens
Dimensions	10.7 in x 9.8 in x 2.1 in
Material	Food grade steel (non-toxic, BPA free)
Max Heat Resistance	Up to 480F (preheat recommended)
Cleaning	Dishwasher safe; avoid abrasive scrubbers
Design	Non-stick mesh air fryer basket / wire rack

Our Verdict

The mesh steel air fryer tray is a sensible replacement for owners of the specified Cuisinart toaster ovens: it restores airflow, improves crisping, and simplifies cleanup without introducing off-flavors. For the price it represents good value for households that frequently air fry, provided users follow the recommended preheat step to protect the metal and use a liner for very small items.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will this basket fit my Cuisinart TOA-28?
Yes, the basket measures 10.7 in x 9.8 in x 2.1 in and is designed to fit the TOA-28 and AFR-25 oven cavities of similar size.

Is the tray safe to wash in a dishwasher?
Yes, it is dishwasher safe and customers note it cleans up easier than some original trays; avoid abrasive scrubbers to protect the finish.

Do I need to do anything before the first use?
Yes, preheat the basket in the oven at 300F for 10 minutes to stabilize the steel and help prevent deformation on initial use.