Dr. Scholl's Men's Harrington II Work Shoe - Comfortable Shoes

In this review the Dr. Scholl's Men's Harrington II Work Shoe is evaluated as a practical, comfortable work oxford for men who spend long hours on their feet. The bottom line: it is best for professionals who need reliable slip resistance and cushioning without sacrificing a dressier oxford look. The shoe's standout quality is its insole technology that provides clear anatomical cushioning and shock absorption, which testers and users repeatedly cite as the main reason to choose this model for hospitality, retail, and light industrial shifts.

Key Features

• Performance tested: Independent lab testing shows the shoe beats the industry average for comfort and cushioning, making long shifts easier on feet.
• Slip-resistant outsole: The Lock Step Outsole is oil-resistant and meets SATRA TM63 and TM144 standards, giving dependable grip on wet and slick surfaces.
• Construction: Made with majority leather and manmade materials for durability and a professional oxford appearance appropriate for uniformed environments.
• Fit: Lace-up front with four-eyelet lacing allows a secure, adjustable fit and roomy toe space for comfort during long wear.
• Midsole support: The midsole reduces foot pressure and absorbs shock, helping reduce fatigue over extended standing or walking shifts.
• Lightweight movement: The overall lightweight construction lets the shoe move with you rather than feel heavy on the foot.

Who It's For

The Harrington II is aimed at men who need a dress-appropriate work shoe that still performs in slippery, demanding conditions: servers, retail associates, front-of-house staff, and many uniformed roles will appreciate the slip-resistant outsole and cushioned insole. Its oxford styling also suits workplaces that require a more formal shoe than a stout work boot.

Those who work in heavy construction, environments with sharp debris, or who need reinforced toe protection should look elsewhere, as this shoe is designed as a dress-style work oxford rather than a safety toe or fully industrial work shoe. Shoppers seeking extreme long-term durability might compare build reports carefully, since some users report mixed longevity results.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Comfortable anatomical insole technology that cushions and supports over long shifts.
• Reliable oil- and slip-resistant Lock Step Outsole that passed multiple SATRA standards and surface tests.
• Professional oxford styling in mostly leather for a clean, uniform-ready look.
• Lightweight construction and a shock-absorbing midsole that reduce foot fatigue.

Cons

• Build quality and durability reports are mixed among customers; some report wear at the sole or stitching over time.
• Not intended as a safety toe or heavy construction boot, so it lacks industrial reinforcements.

Specifications

Brand	Dr. Scholl's Shoes
Style	Men's work oxford
Upper materials	Majority leather, balance manmade
Outsole	Oil-resistant, slip-resistant Lock Step Outsole (meets SATRA TM63, TM144)
Lacing	Four-eyelet lace-up
Midsole	Shock-absorbing midsole that reduces foot pressure
Weight	Lightweight construction

Our Verdict

For men who need a smart-looking work shoe with proven slip resistance and standout cushioning, the Harrington II offers strong value for hospitality and retail professionals. It pairs a comfortable insole, tested grip, and leather styling at a price point that suits uniformed workplaces; shoppers seeking heavy-duty industrial protection should consider a dedicated safety boot instead.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these shoes truly slip-resistant?
Yes. The Lock Step Outsole is oil-resistant and meets SATRA TM63 and TM144 standards and passed additional surface tests for tile and steel plate.

What are they made of?
The uppers are majority leather with manmade components for balance, and they use a non-marking rubber outsole.

Do they provide good cushioning for all-day wear?
Customers and lab testing highlight the anatomical insole and shock-absorbing midsole as delivering notable comfort and reduced foot pressure during long shifts.