Dr. Scholl's Men's Harrington II Work Shoe - Comfortable Slip

In this review of the Harrington II work shoe, the bottom line is clear: men who spend long shifts on their feet and need reliable grip will appreciate the comfort and slip resistance above all else. The shoe is presented as a practical work oxford that balances a leather-forward build with cushioning designed to reduce foot pressure. For those prioritizing a low-profile, lace-up dress style that still performs on slick floors, this shoe delivers its strongest benefit in underfoot comfort and tested traction.

Key Features

• Performance tested: Independent lab testing shows cushioning and comfort above industry average, making it suitable for all-day wear.
• Slip-resistant outsole: The Lock Step Outsole is oil-resistant and slip-resistant, meeting SATRA TM63 and TM144 standards for confidence on wet or greasy surfaces.
• Leather construction: Majority leather upper provides a professional dress oxford look while retaining durability and structure.
• Anatomical insole: Insole Technology delivers targeted cushioning and support to reduce foot pressure and absorb shock through long shifts.
• Lightweight movement: The midsole and overall construction are designed to move with the foot, reducing fatigue during extended standing or walking.
• Non-marking outsole: A rubber outsole that avoids scuffing floors while offering tested grip on tile and steel plate surfaces.

Who It's For

The Harrington II suits men working in hospitality, retail, or light industrial settings who need a neat oxford appearance without sacrificing traction and cushioning. It is best for people who value a comfortable insole and a shoe that handles slippery floors like vinyl tile and eurotile while still looking office-appropriate.

Those who require heavy-duty, long-term ruggedness or specialized protective features such as steel toes or full waterproofing should look elsewhere. Additionally, shoppers focused only on maximal longevity may find mixed reports on long-term sole and stitching durability and might prefer a work shoe with reinforced warranty or heavy-duty construction.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Comfort: Many customers report excellent cushioning and roomy toe fit for extended wear.
• Grip: The Lock Step Outsole provides strong slip resistance on multiple tested surfaces.
• Style: Leather oxford appearance fits uniform and business-casual dress codes.
• Value: Positive feedback on overall quality and cost-effectiveness for a work shoe.

Cons

• Durability concerns: Some users report issues with sole separation or stitching after prolonged use.
• Not a heavy-protection shoe: Lacks specialized safety features like steel toe or full waterproof membranes.

Specifications

Our Verdict

The Harrington II is a solid choice for workers who need a presentable oxford with tested slip resistance and superior cushioning for long shifts. It offers good value for its comfort and grip, though buyers seeking extreme durability or protective safety features should consider alternatives. For most who balance appearance and performance, it is a dependable everyday work shoe.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these shoes truly slip resistant?
Yes. The Lock Step Outsole is oil-resistant and meets SATRA TM63 and TM144 standards and passed additional surface tests for common floor types.

What are the uppers made of?
The uppers are majority leather with manmade materials making up the remainder for strength and structure.

Do they provide good cushioning for long shifts?
Yes. The insole technology and shock-absorbing midsole are designed to reduce foot pressure and improve comfort over extended wear.