Irish Setter Ashby 6in Aluminum Safety Toe Work Boot - Durable

In this review the Irish Setter Ashby 6in aluminum safety toe work boot is evaluated for tradespeople who need a balance of protection, comfort, and long life. The single biggest reason to buy is its combination of a lightweight aluminum safety toe and a resoleable Goodyear Welt platform that together deliver safety without excessive weight and a clear path to extended use. The review focuses on construction, everyday comfort, and how the boot performs against heat, slip, impact, compression, and electrical hazard standards.

Key Features

• Safety certification: Meets ASTM F2413-18 M/I/C, EH and ASTM F3445-21 SR standards to protect against impact, compression, electrical hazards and slip risks on the jobsite.
• Aluminum safety toe: Provides a lighter protective barrier than steel while still shielding toes from common construction and industrial hazards.
• Heat resistant outsole: The HRO rubber-EVA Traction Tred sole resists melting at high temperatures and offers reliable traction on hot surfaces.
• Durable leather upper: Oiled full grain leather gives long-lasting abrasion resistance and a worn-in look that holds up with regular use.
• Removable polyurethane footbed: Delivers cushioned support for all-day standing and can be replaced to maintain comfort over time.
• Resoleable Goodyear Welt: Welt construction prevents water intrusion and allows the sole to be replaced to extend the life of the boot.

Who It's For

The Ashby is best for construction workers, mechanics, and tradespeople who need certified impact and compression protection but prefer a lighter toe option and the ability to resole their boots. Its heat resistant sole and slip design also suit those who encounter hot surfaces or greasy floors.

Those who need an ultra-narrow fit, or who must have a steel toe for specific site rules, should look elsewhere. Also, buyers seeking an immediately perfect fit may want to try on the boot first, as customer feedback shows varied experiences with sizing and break-in.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Lightweight protective aluminum toe reduces fatigue compared with heavier toe designs.
• Solid construction with oiled full grain leather and Goodyear Welt for long-term repairability.
• Comfortable removable polyurethane footbed that supports long shifts on the feet.
• HRO Traction Tred outsole resists heat and provides dependable slip resistance.

Cons

• Fit can be inconsistent for some buyers, so trying a size before committing is advisable.
• Some customers report durability issues in specific areas after months of heavy use.

Specifications

Our Verdict

The Irish Setter Ashby 6in aluminum safety toe boot is a practical choice for workers who want certified protection without the weight penalty of a steel toe, paired with a resoleable build that supports long-term value. It balances comfort, heat resistance, and repairability, making it a strong option for many jobsite roles - but potential buyers should confirm fit before purchase.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these boots electrically rated?
Yes, they meet EH electrical hazard resistance as part of their ASTM safety certifications.

Can the soles be replaced?
Yes, the Goodyear Welt construction allows the boots to be resoled to extend overall lifespan.

How does the aluminum toe compare to steel?
Aluminum offers adequate impact and compression protection while being lighter than steel, which reduces fatigue during long shifts.