Irish Setter Ashby 6in Soft Toe Work Boot - Comfortable, Resoleable

In this review of the Irish Setter Ashby 6in soft toe work boot, the bottom line is simple: these boots are built for workers who need long-lasting leather construction and a heat- and slip-resistant sole without the weight of a steel toe. The reviewer found the boots to be notably comfortable out of the box thanks to a removable polyurethane footbed and soft full grain oiled leather, while the Goodyear Welt construction promises a resoleable platform that extends service life for tradespeople who value repairable footwear.

Key Features

• Safety compliance: Meets ASTM F2892-18, ASTM F3445-21 and EH standards so wearers get heat, slip and electrical hazard resistance required on many job sites.
• Soft toe protection: A soft toe design provides a protective layer while keeping the boot lighter and more flexible than hard-toe alternatives.
• Durable upper: Oiled full grain leather resists wear and softens over time for a combination of toughness and break-in comfort.
• Comfort system: The removable polyurethane footbed delivers cushioning that many reviewers compared to athletic-shoe comfort for long shifts on concrete.
• Resoleable construction: Goodyear Welt sole assembly keeps water out and allows resoling to extend the useful life of the boot.
• Heat resistant outsole: HRO rubber-EVA Traction Tred sole resists melting on hot surfaces up to at least 475F for reliable performance near heat.

Who It's For

The Irish Setter Ashby is best for tradespeople, utility workers and anyone who spends long hours on their feet and wants a comfortable, repairable leather boot with safety ratings for heat, slip and electrical hazards. Users who prioritize a lighter, more flexible soft toe over a safety toe will appreciate the comfort and reduced weight.

Those who need a narrow fit or who require a composite or steel toe for impact protection should consider alternatives; also, buyers who expect a perfectly uniform fit every time should note some customers report variance in width and sole longevity.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Well-built oiled full grain leather upper that breaks in comfortably.
• Compliant HRO and EH outsole gives confidence around heat, slippery surfaces and electrical hazards.
• Removable polyurethane footbed offers cushioning similar to athletic shoes for long shifts.
• Goodyear Welt construction enables resoling to lengthen the boot's service life.

Cons

• Some customers report the sole separating after extended use, so long-term sole durability can vary.
• Sizing and width appear inconsistent for some buyers, with a few finding the fit narrower than expected.

Specifications

Brand	Irish Setter
Model	Ashby, Men's, 6in
Toe type	Soft toe
Upper material	Oiled full grain leather
Outsole	HRO rubber-EVA Traction Tred
Safety standards	ASTM F2892-18, ASTM F3445-21, EH, SR
Construction	Goodyear Welt (resoleable)

Our Verdict

The Irish Setter Ashby 6in soft toe work boot is a strong choice for workers who want comfortable, leather footwear that meets heat, slip and electrical hazard standards and can be resoled to extend its life. It represents good value for those prioritizing all-day cushioning and durable upper materials, though buyers who need consistent width or heavy-duty sole longevity should verify fit and inspect seams over time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these boots rated for electrical hazards?
Yes, the Ashby meets EH requirements and is rated for electrical hazard protection as noted in the safety standards.

Can the sole be replaced if it wears out?
Yes, the Goodyear Welt construction is resoleable, which helps extend the boot's service life.

Do these run true to size?
Fit varies by foot shape; many find the length true but some customers report a narrower feel, so try them on or check sizing notes when ordering.