Irish Setter Ashby Mens 6in Soft Toe Work Boot - Durable Comfort

In this review of the Irish Setter Ashby 6in soft toe work boot, the bottom line is simple: these boots are built for workers who need long-lasting leather construction and comfortable cushioning on demanding days. The reviewer found the combination of oiled full grain leather, a removable polyurethane footbed, and a Goodyear Welt resoleable platform makes these boots a strong candidate for tradespeople and anyone who spends long hours on their feet. The single biggest reason to buy is the blend of comfort and serviceable safety features that cover heat, slip and electrical hazard concerns.

Key Features

• ASTM-rated safety: The boot meets ASTM F2892-18, EH and ASTM F3445-21 SR standards, providing protection against slip, heat and electrical hazards on many worksites.
• Soft toe protection: The soft toe offers a protective layer while keeping the profile lighter and more flexible than composite or steel options.
• Durable leather upper: Oiled full grain leather resists wear and maintains a classic work-boot look that holds up to regular use.
• Comfortable cushioning: A removable polyurethane footbed delivers long-lasting comfort and reduces fatigue on extended shifts.
• Resoleable Goodyear Welt: Welt construction prevents water intrusion and allows the sole to be replaced, extending the boot life.
• Heat resistant outsole: HRO rubber-EVA Traction Tred soles resist melting at high temperatures and are designed for use on hot surfaces.

Who It's For

These boots are best for construction, industrial, and utility workers who need reliable leather boots with safety-rated features and all-day comfort. The resoleable Goodyear Welt will appeal to people who expect to keep the same pair for seasons and prefer a traditional, serviceable work-boot that can be repaired.

Shoppers who require a composite or steel toe for higher impact-rated jobs should look elsewhere, and anyone needing a very wide toe box may find the fit narrower than expected. Those seeking a lighter, athletic-style work shoe might prefer a trainer-style option over this more classic boot.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Solid construction with oiled full grain leather for long-term durability and an attractive finish.
• Meets multiple safety standards including heat, slip and electrical hazard resistance for versatile jobsite use.
• Comfort-focused removable polyurethane footbed provides cushioning comparable to softer footwear and improves all-day wear.
• Resoleable Goodyear Welt design reduces long-term ownership cost by allowing new soles to be attached.

Cons

• Some users report the sole separating over time, so longevity may vary with heavy use.
• Fit can run narrow for some feet, so trying on for width or ordering with that in mind is recommended.

Specifications

Brand	Irish Setter
Style	Ashby 6in soft toe work boot
Upper	Oiled full grain leather
Sole	HRO rubber-EVA Traction Tred outsole
Safety ratings	ASTM F2892-18, EH, ASTM F3445-21 SR
Construction	Goodyear Welt, resoleable platform
Comfort features	Removable polyurethane footbed

Our Verdict

The Irish Setter Ashby 6in soft toe boot is a practical choice for tradespeople who want durable leather, ASTM-rated protection, and a comfortable cushioned footbed without a heavy toe cap. It offers strong value thanks to repairable Goodyear Welt construction, though buyers with wide feet or those needing maximum sole longevity should consider fit and usage needs before purchasing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these boots electrical hazard rated?
Yes, they meet EH electrical hazard standards and provide protection against open circuits under specified conditions.

Can the sole be replaced if it wears out?
Yes, the Goodyear Welt construction is resoleable, allowing a cobbler to fit a new sole to extend the boot life.

Do these boots run true to size?
Sizing is mixed in user reports; many find length accurate but some note a narrower fit, so try them on or consider width when ordering.