LCL CF258A 58A Black Toner Cartridge 2-Pack - Reliable High Yield

In this review of the LCL CF258A 58A black toner cartridge 2-pack, the bottom line is simple: it is a practical, cost-conscious replacement for users of compatible HP LaserJet Pro models who want high page yield and stable printing. The reviewer found the cartridges deliver strong print quality at an estimated high capacity of 3,000 pages each at 5% coverage, and the use of an OEM recycled chip avoids firmware lockouts while only suppressing the remaining toner level readout. For offices or home workgroups that need dependable monochrome output without OEM pricing, this is worth considering.

Key Features

• With Chip: Uses an OEM recycled chip so the cartridge continues to work after firmware updates even if the printer no longer reports remaining toner level.
• High Capacity: Rated for about 3,000 pages at 5% coverage, which helps reduce how often cartridges are replaced for typical office tasks.
• Compatible Models: Designed to replace HP 58A/58X series in a range of LaserJet Pro M304, M404 and MFP M428 printers to keep common business machines running.
• Reliable Print Quality: LCL reports controlled toner particle size and high transfer rate to produce clear text and a glossy monochrome finish for documents.
• Individual Packaging: Each cartridge ships in its own box for safer long-term storage and to reduce risk of damage or toner leakage.

Who It's For

The LCL CF258A 2-pack is best for small offices, home offices, and workgroups that rely on HP LaserJet Pro M304/M404/M428 series printers and want to lower consumable costs without sacrificing legible, sharp black-and-white output. It suits users who print mixed documents and need a high-yield option to avoid frequent swaps.

Power users who require fully accurate toner-level reporting or prefer OEM warranty-backed cartridges may want to look elsewhere. Likewise, buyers who demand the original manufacturer's packaging or integrated printer status features should consider OEM supplies instead.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Good print quality with clear text and respectable gloss for monochrome documents.
• High rated page yield of around 3,000 pages at 5% coverage reduces replacement frequency.
• OEM recycled chip helps maintain printer compatibility across firmware updates.

Cons

• Printer may show a "low toner" message and will not display an accurate remaining toner level, which some users find inconvenient.
• Some customers reported mixed impressions of cartridge sturdiness compared with OEM units.

Specifications

Product	LCL CF258A 58A Black Toner Cartridge (2-Pack)
Compatible Printers	HP LaserJet Pro M304/M404 and MFP M428 series
Yield	High Capacity; approx. 3,000 pages at 5% coverage (Letter/A4)
Chip	OEM recycled chip included; printer may not show remaining toner level
Quality Standards	Manufactured in ISO 9001/14001; STMC; CE; ROHS certified factory
Packaging	Individual box per cartridge for long-term storage and protection

Our Verdict

The LCL CF258A 58A 2-pack is a solid budget-friendly choice for users of compatible HP LaserJet Pro models who prioritize yield and consistent print quality over OEM status displays. It delivers reliable monochrome output and reduced replacement frequency, making it a sensible value alternative for offices and home users who can tolerate a suppressed toner-level indicator.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the cartridge work after a printer firmware update?
The cartridges use an OEM recycled chip designed to remain compatible after firmware updates, so printing continues normally even if the toner level is not shown.

What if the printer shows a low toner warning?
If the printer prompts a low toner message you can ignore it; the cartridge will continue to function and print normally until actual toner depletion.

How many pages can I expect from these cartridges?
The cartridges are rated for about 3,000 pages each at 5% coverage (Letter/A4), suitable for moderate to heavy black-and-white printing.