Merrell Womens Encore Ice 5 - Cozy Waterproof Slip-On Air

In this review of the Merrell Womens Encore Ice 5 the bottom line is simple: these are cozy, winter-ready slip-ons best suited for someone who wants warmth and effortless on/off convenience without sacrificing sensible traction. The shoe stands out for its sheepskin lining and premium pig suede upper that make it feel soft and insulated from cold weather. Reviewers repeatedly highlight comfort and arch support as strong points, while fit can vary, so consider trying your usual size and checking return options before committing.

Key Features

• Waterproof pig suede leather upper: Keeps feet dry in damp winter conditions while retaining a soft, premium feel.
• Sheepskin lining: Provides plush insulation that makes the shoe feel like a cozy hug during cold months.
• Removable footbed: Allows for easy cleaning or replacement with a custom orthotic if extra support is needed.
• Merrell Air Cushion in the heel: Absorbs shock and adds stability for comfortable walking over varied surfaces.
• Merrell sticky rubber outsole: Delivers durable traction that grips when and where you need it on slick or wet ground.
• FloatPro comfort midsole: Offers responsive cushioning for daily wear and extended indoor-outdoor use.

Who It's For

The Encore Ice 5 is ideal for women who want a warm, easy-on winter slip-on with real traction and supportive comfort. It suits daily wear around town, short walks in cold weather, and anyone who values a plush lining and simple convenience without lacing.

Those who need precise sizing for performance activities or those seeking a lightweight, breathable summer shoe should look elsewhere; this model is built for warmth and structure rather than minimal packing or high-ventilation needs. Also, shoppers expecting a very narrow fit may want to try on or size carefully because fit feedback is mixed.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Plush sheepskin lining and FloatPro midsole create excellent winter comfort.
• Solid arch support and heel air cushion improve stability for walking.
• Waterproof pig suede and sticky rubber outsole deliver reliable wet-weather performance.
• Removable footbed makes cleaning or orthotic swapping straightforward.

Cons

• Fit can be mixed between customers, so some may need to size up or down for the best fit.
• Because of the warm lining and structure, the shoe is less suitable for warm-weather wear.

Specifications

Our Verdict

The Merrell Womens Encore Ice 5 is a practical, comfortable winter slip-on that feels warm and supportive for daily winter use. Its waterproof suede, sheepskin lining, and sticky outsole make it a good value for shoppers who prioritize warmth, traction, and easy on/off convenience, provided they confirm the best size for their feet.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these shoes waterproof?
Yes, the upper is waterproof pig suede leather designed to shed moisture in wet winter conditions.

Can I replace the insole with a custom orthotic?
Yes, the shoe has a removable footbed that allows for replacement with a custom orthotic.

Do they run true to size?
Fit is mixed among customers; some find them true to size while others report sizing variation, so try your normal size and check the store return policy.