Merrell Womens Encore Ice 5 - Cozy Waterproof Slip-On Loafers

Our review of the Merrell Womens Encore Ice 5 finds it is best for women seeking a warm, easy-on winter slip-on that still performs on damp surfaces. The single biggest reason to buy is the combination of a waterproof pig suede upper and sheepskin lining that keeps feet warm and dry while the Merrell Air Cushion in the heel delivers surprise stability and shock absorption during everyday wear. Overall it reads like a practical, comfy moccasin designed for cold months rather than high-performance hiking.

Key Features

• Waterproof pig suede upper: keeps feet dry in wet winter conditions while preserving a soft, premium look.
• Sheepskin lining: provides plush insulation and a cozy fit that feels warm during cold-weather wear.
• Removable footbed: allows for easy cleaning or replacement with custom orthotics for personalized comfort.
• Merrell Air Cushion in the heel: absorbs shock on pavement and adds rearfoot stability for more confident steps.
• Merrell sticky rubber outsole: offers durable traction that grips on slick or icy surfaces where you need it most.
• FloatPro comfort midsole: gives a cushioned ride that reduces fatigue for daily use.

Who It's For

The Encore Ice 5 is ideal for someone who spends a lot of time walking around town in winter, wants an easy slip-on shoe, and values warmth and comfort over a rugged hiking boot. It suits commuters, casual walkers, and anyone who wants arch support and a stable heel in a moccasin silhouette.

Shoppers who need aggressive ankle support, a fully technical winter boot for deep snow, or a narrow race-style fit should look elsewhere; the Encore Ice 5 is designed as a cozy, supportive slip-on and has received mixed feedback on exact fit, so trying your usual size or consulting retailer guidance is recommended.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Comfortable, warm sheepskin lining makes them feel like a cozy indoor-outdoor slipper.
• Waterproof pig suede upper and sticky rubber outsole increase usability in wet winter conditions.
• Good arch support and Merrell Air Cushion add stability and shock absorption for daily wear.
• Removable footbed allows for customization or replacement.

Cons

• Fit is mixed among customers; some report true-to-size while others note sizing issues, so fit may vary by foot shape.
• Not intended as a heavy-duty winter boot for deep snow or technical trails.

Specifications

Brand	Merrell
Model	Encore Ice 5
Upper	Waterproof pig suede leather
Lining	Sheepskin
Midsole	FloatPro comfort midsole with Merrell Air Cushion
Outsole	Merrell sticky rubber outsole with durable traction
Footbed	Removable footbed

Our Verdict

The Merrell Womens Encore Ice 5 is a strong choice for anyone wanting a warm, easy-on winter slip-on that handles wet pavements with confidence. It delivers excellent comfort, arch support, and reliable traction for everyday winter wear, making it good value for shoppers prioritizing warmth and ease over technical performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these shoes waterproof?
Yes, the pig suede upper is waterproof and designed to keep feet dry in wet winter conditions.

Can I replace the footbed with orthotics?
Yes, the Encore Ice 5 has a removable footbed that can be swapped for custom orthotics.

Do they run true to size?
Fit is mixed according to customers; some find them true-to-size while others report sizing variability, so trying your usual size or checking retailer guidance is advised.