Metal Roofing Screw 12 x 1-1/2 in Brown (250) - Re-Grip Replacement

In this review the Metal Roofing Screw (250) 12 x 1-1/2 in Brown from Jake Sales is judged on durability and fit for replacing failed fasteners on metal roofs and siding. The review finds these screws best for DIYers and contractors needing a reliable re-grip option when old screws or small nails are loose and will not hold. The single biggest reason to buy is the combination of a 1/4 in hex head and a ~5/8 in EPDM washer that restores clamping and provides a weather seal where previous fasteners failed.

Key Features

• Re-Grip design: Specifically intended to replace loose or failed nails and smaller screws, making repair work straightforward and reliable.
• 1/4 in hex head: Provides a firm grip for standard hex drivers, reducing cam-out and speeding installation on roofing and siding.
• ~5/8 in EPDM washer: Delivers a consistent seal under the head to resist water intrusion and improve the life of the repair.
• #12.219 in shaft: Thicker shaft than smaller fasteners offers better holding power in wood substrates and aged roof material.
• 1-1/2 in under head length: Suits common metal-to-wood fastening needs without excess thread or unnecessary penetration.
• Colored polyurethane coating: Matches common roofing colors closely, keeping repaired areas visually consistent (color may vary).

Who It's For

These screws are aimed at homeowners repairing small areas of metal roofing or siding, and contractors performing targeted replacements where previous fasteners have worked loose. The packaging of 250 is convenient for multi-point repairs on barns, sheds, carports and sections of roof where several failed fasteners exist.

Those looking for specialty fasteners for metal-to-metal fastening, very long penetration, or decorative exposed fasteners may want to consider different screws. If precise color matching is essential, test a small sample first since the coating color can vary slightly from manufacturer to manufacturer.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Good sealing performance thanks to the ~5/8 in EPDM washer that reduces leak risk at the head.
• Durable driver interface with a 1/4 in hex head that works well with common hex drivers.
• Thicker.219 in shaft (#12) gives stronger hold in wood compared with smaller fasteners.
• Polyurethane coating provides a color-matched finish for less visible repairs.

Cons

• Color may vary slightly, so exact visual match is not guaranteed for critical restorations.
• Designed for metal-to-wood or repair replacements; not marketed as a primary metal-to-metal roofing screw option.

Specifications

Quantity	250 screws
Length (under head)	1-1/2 in
Shaft diameter	.219 in (#12)
Head type	1/4 in hex head
Washer	~5/8 in EPDM washer
Point type	Sharp point for metal to wood siding
Coating	Polyurethane colored finish (brown)

Our Verdict

For anyone repairing loose or failed fasteners on metal roofs and wood-backed siding, these Re-Grip 12 x 1-1/2 in screws offer a practical, cost-effective solution. They combine a reliable sealing washer, a strong #12 shaft and a user-friendly 1/4 in hex head, making them solid value for targeted repairs where restoring clamp and seal matters most.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can these screws be used on wood-backed metal roofing?
Yes, they are designed for metal-to-wood applications and work well when replacing smaller failed nails or screws.

Do the screws come sealed against water?
The ~5/8 in EPDM washer under the head provides a water-resistant seal to reduce leak risk at each fastener.

Will the brown coating perfectly match my roof?
The polyurethane coating closely matches common roofing colors but color may vary, so test a small area if an exact match is required.