My Dinner with Andre (The Criterion Collection) DVD - Thoughtful

In this review of My Dinner with Andre (The Criterion Collection) the bottom line is simple: this DVD is for viewers who value conversation-driven cinema and philosophical exploration over plot. The film places Wallace Shawn and Andre Gregory in a single, intimate setting where dialogue becomes the engine of the experience, and Criterion's presentation keeps the focus on performance and ideas. Those looking for action or polished widescreen spectacle should look elsewhere, but anyone seeking a thoughtful, talk-driven film will find this edition rewarding.

Key Features

• Two principal performers: Wallace Shawn and Andre Gregory deliver extended, nuanced exchanges that carry the film and reward close attention.
• Direction by Louis Malle: Malle frames the restaurant setting with unobtrusive precision so the conversation remains the central element.
• Criterion Collection edition: This release preserves the film as a collectible edition with special features and careful presentation for collectors.
• Full frame presentation: The Special Edition Full Frame 1.33 aspect preserves the film's original theatrical framing and intimate composition.
• English audio: Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono keeps the soundtrack faithful and centered on the voices and the room ambiance.
• Additional release material: Extras and special features add context for viewers who want background on the production and the performers.

Who It's For

This DVD is aimed at cinephiles, theater fans, and anyone who appreciates a sustained intellectual exchange on subjects like love, death, and personal meaning. If you enjoy films where character and conversation reveal ideas slowly, the Criterion packaging and extras add collectible value and viewing depth.

It is not intended for viewers seeking fast pacing, visual spectacle, or action-based entertainment; the film's emphasis is on dialogue and reflection, and some viewers may find the visual grain or static framing less engaging than contemporary restorations.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Outstanding dialogue and performances that make the film rewarding on repeated viewings.
• Criterion Collection release with special features that provide useful context for fans and collectors.
• Faithful full frame presentation and audio that preserve the film's original intimacy.

Cons

• Visual quality is reported as mixed by customers, with some noting grain or less-than-perfect print quality in places.

Specifications

Title	My Dinner with Andre (The Criterion Collection) DVD
Principal cast	Wallace Shawn, Andre Gregory
Director	Louis Malle
Format	DVD Special Edition Full Frame - 1.33
Audio	Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono - English
Extras	Additional release material and special features

Our Verdict

This Criterion DVD is a strong purchase for viewers who prioritize conversation and performance over visual razzle-dazzle. The edition offers thoughtful extras and a presentation that keeps the focus on the interaction between Shawn and Gregory; despite some reports of grainy prints, it represents good value for fans of intelligent, talk-driven cinema.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this the original theatrical aspect ratio?
Yes, the release uses a Special Edition Full Frame 1.33 presentation consistent with the film's original framing.

What audio options are included?
The DVD includes Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono audio in English focused on clear dialogue reproduction.

Does this edition include extras?
Yes, the Criterion Collection release lists additional release material and special features to provide context and background.