Naturalizer Kelly Flat Women's Dress Shoe - Comfortable Mary Jane

In this review of the Naturalizer Kelly Flat, the bottom line is simple: these are dressy yet practical flats for someone who wants a classic Mary Jane look with reliable all-day comfort. The reviewer found the combination of soft leather uppers, a supportive Contour+ Comfort footbed, and an adjustable strap made these flats a go-to choice for work, travel, or events where standing and walking are required. Fit varies for some customers, but the shoe's build and materials make it worth trying for anyone who prioritizes comfort in a dress shoe.

Key Features

• Mary Jane inspired strap: The adjustable buckle strap keeps the foot secure while walking and adds a dressy, classic silhouette.
• Leather upper options: Available in leather, patent leather, or metallic leather, each finish offers a polished look that holds up well to regular wear.
• Contour+ Comfort technology: The molded footbed is designed to follow the contours of a woman's foot for better support and reduced fatigue over a full day.
• Low heel and non-slip outsole: The 1/2 in heel and non-slip outsole provide a slight lift without sacrificing stability on slick surfaces.
• Inclusive sizing and widths: Offered in medium and wide widths so wearers with different foot shapes can find a better fit.
• Conscious packaging: The shoe boxes are made from 80% recycled paper and printed with soy-based ink, reflecting an effort to use more sustainable materials.

Who It's For

The Kelly Flat is well suited to women who need a refined, office-appropriate flat that still feels comfortable for long shifts or days on the go. It works for people who value a structured, classic design with a secure strap and appreciate the feel of genuine leather or a polished patent finish.

Those who should look elsewhere include shoppers who require very narrow widths, chunky cushioning for severe foot conditions, or an athletic-style sole - this is a dress flat focused on everyday support and style rather than heavy orthotic correction or sport performance.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Comfortable Contour+ Comfort footbed gives reliable all-day support.
• Leather and patent leather options look high quality and feel soft on the foot.
• Adjustable buckle strap secures the foot and keeps the shoe from slipping.
• Consciously packaged with recycled materials for reduced environmental impact.

Cons

• Sizing feedback is mixed; some customers find them true to size while others report they run small, so trying them on is recommended.
• As a low-heel dress flat, it does not provide the same level of shock absorption as athletic footwear.

Specifications

Style	Mary Jane inspired flat
Upper material	Leather, patent leather, or metallic leather
Toe	Closed round toe
Heel height	1/2 in
Outsole	Non-slip outsole
Widths	Medium and wide
Comfort tech	Contour+ Comfort footbed

Our Verdict

The Naturalizer Kelly Flat is a smart buy for someone who wants a dependable, comfortable dress flat with a classic Mary Jane look; its leather options, supportive Contour+ Comfort footbed, and non-slip outsole make it good value for everyday office wear or events where standing is expected. Try your normal size but consider ordering a second size if you are between sizes, since some wearers report a slightly small fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these true to size?
Fit is mixed: many find them true to size but some customers report they run small, so try your normal size and consider an alternate if between sizes.

What materials are used?
The upper comes in leather, patent leather, or metallic leather with a Contour+ Comfort footbed and a non-slip outsole.

Are they suitable for wide feet?
Yes, the Kelly Flat is available in medium and wide widths to accommodate wider foot shapes.