New York Yankees 59FIFTY Fitted Cap - Authentic MLB Look
New York Yankees 59FIFTY Fitted Cap - Authentic MLB Look
Price subject to change. Tap below for current.
Couldn't load pickup availability
Our review of the New Era Mens New York Yankees MLB Authentic Collection 59FIFTY Cap finds it best for fans who want an authentic, structured fitted hat with a sharp team presentation. The single biggest reason to buy is the unmistakable embroidered Yankees logo and official MLB touches that deliver a genuine game-day look; the cap's 100% polyester build and New Era flag on the side make it feel like an official piece of fan apparel rather than a casual fashion cap. Buyers should note fit can vary, so measure before ordering if precise sizing matters.
Key Features
- Official team embroidery: The embroidered New York Yankees logo on the front panels provides an accurate, high-contrast team identity that stays visible over time.
- Authentic MLB details: A stitched MLB Batterman logo at the rear and the New Era flag on the side confirm this is an officially licensed cap for collectors and fans.
- Durable polyester construction: Made of 100% polyester woven fabric, the cap maintains its shape and resists moisture better than cheap cotton blends.
- Structured 59FIFTY fit: The New Era Authentic Collection 59FIFTY design delivers a traditional fitted silhouette favored by fans and players alike.
- Gray undervisor: The gray undervisor reduces glare and preserves the cap's classic aesthetic when worn outdoors.
Who It's For
The cap is ideal for committed New York Yankees fans and collectors who want an authentic, officially licensed piece to wear on game days or display with other memorabilia. It also suits anyone who prefers a structured fitted hat over adjustable styles and values branded details like the New Era flag.
Shoppers who need an adjustable one-size-fits-all cap or those particularly concerned about receiving an unbent brim should look at other listings; some customers report variations in fit and occasional shipping-related misshaping that require reshaping on arrival.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Clear, authentic embroidered Yankees logo that looks true to team branding.
- Official MLB Batterman and New Era flag details that verify licensing and quality.
- 100% polyester woven construction offers durability and easier care than many cotton caps.
- Classic 59FIFTY fitted silhouette favored for its clean lines and structured look.
Cons
- Fit is mixed among reviewers, so exact size selection matters and returns may be needed for the best fit.
- Some customers report the brim arriving bent or misshapen, indicating occasional shipping or packaging issues.
Specifications
| Brand | New Era |
| Collection | New Era Authentic Collection 59FIFTY |
| Material | 100% Polyester |
| Team Logo | Embroidered on Front |
| Brand Logo | New Era Flag on Side |
| Undervisor | Gray |
| Style Number / SKU | 11591128 / NEC-11591128-BKBK |
Our Verdict
The New York Yankees 59FIFTY fitted cap is a solid pick for fans who prioritize authenticity and a classic structured look; the embroidered team logo, MLB detailing, and polyester build make it a durable, official option. Buyers who need a precise fit or worry about shipping shape should inspect sizing carefully, but for most collectors and game-day wearers it represents good value as an authentic team cap.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this an officially licensed MLB cap?
Yes. The cap features the MLB Batterman logo at the rear and New Era branding, indicating it is an officially licensed product.
What is the material and care?
The cap is 100% polyester woven; spot-clean or hand-wash as directed for best shape retention.
Will the brim arrive flat or bent?
Most arrive correctly shaped, but some customers report the brim can be misshapen after shipping; light reshaping or steaming will usually restore the brim.
Editor's Take
The 59FIFTY Yankees fitted cap offers authentic embroidered team branding, official MLB details, and a durable 100% polyester build, making it a strong choice for fans who want a structured, collectible hat; check sizing and inspect the brim on arrival.

Recently viewed
Recently viewed products will appear here as customers browse the store.