Polished Brass 4-1/4 in Post Style Kitchen Basket Strainer - Large Fit

Our review of the Polished Brass 4-1/4 in Post Style Kitchen Basket Strainer finds it is best for homeowners replacing or upgrading drains on double bowl sinks with a garbage disposal. The biggest reason to buy is its combination of a large 4-1/4 in rim and a removable stopper that both looks finished and works with most ISE-style disposals, so installation yields a clean, coordinated sink without custom parts. Installation notes and finish options make it a practical choice for projects where appearance matters as much as function.

Key Features

• Large rim diameter: The 4-1/4 in rim gives a substantial, finished look that covers minor sink imperfections and matches larger sink openings.
• Disposal compatible: The included waste disposal flange fits most ISE, Emerson, Kenmore, and Grainger disposals so replacement is straightforward for common systems.
• Removable stopper: The 3-1/4 in diameter, 1-1/4 in tall stopper with rubber rim seals reliably and lifts out for easy cleaning.
• Designed for double sinks: Specifically intended for double bowl kitchen sinks with disposal installations, simplifying selection for that layout.
• Finish options: The polished brass finish provides a warm, traditional appearance to coordinate with matching fixtures.

Who It's For

This strainer is ideal for homeowners and handymen replacing a drain in a double bowl sink that uses a garbage disposal, who want a visible, polished brass match to their kitchen fixtures. It suits anyone who prefers a post style basket that lifts to open and drops to close, combining simple mechanical action with a decorative rim.

It is less appropriate for single-bowl sinks without disposals or for installations that require a nonstandard flange diameter; installers should also note the manufacturer advises using silicone seal rather than plumber's putty for proper sealing.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Looks great in a polished brass finish and provides a cohesive look with brass faucets and hardware.
• Ease of installation for common disposal brands makes it a practical replacement part.
• Quality materials and a snug rubber-rim stopper translate to reliable sealing and long-term use.

Cons

• Specifically intended for double bowl sinks with ISE-style disposals, so it may not fit all sink or disposal types without verification.

Specifications

Brand	Westbrass
Rim diameter	4-1/4 in
Sink opening fit	3-1/2 in sink opening
Stopper size	3-1/4 in diameter, 1-1/4 in tall
Compatibility	Fits most ISE, Emerson, Kenmore, Grainger disposals
Included parts	Basket strainer, waste disposal flange, removable stopper

Our Verdict

The polished brass 4-1/4 in post style strainer is a sensible buy for anyone replacing a drain on a double bowl sink with a common garbage disposal. It delivers good value through a large decorative rim, a reliable stopper, and broad disposal compatibility, making it an attractive, trouble-free upgrade for midrange kitchen projects.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will this fit my garbage disposal?
It fits most ISE-style disposals and common brands listed such as Emerson, Kenmore, and Grainger, but buyers should confirm their disposal flange type before purchase.

What sealant should be used?
The manufacturer advises using silicone seal rather than plumber's putty for installation to ensure a proper watertight seal.

Is the stopper removable for cleaning?
Yes, the 3-1/4 in diameter stopper is removable and has a rubber rim for a secure seal and easy maintenance.