Recollections of a Rebel Reefer -1917 Edition James

In this review of Recollections of a Rebel Reefer -1917 the bottom line is straightforward: this reproduction is for readers and researchers who want direct access to a primary-source memoir of naval operations from the Civil War era. The Cornell University Library scan preserves the original pagination and marginalia, making it valuable to historians who prefer working from facsimile copies rather than transcriptions. The single biggest reason to buy is the faithful cover-to-cover scan, which retains the book's marks and notations that can illuminate contemporary reading and use.

Key Features

• Original 1917 edition reproduction: Presents the full text as scanned from the library copy, preserving original pagination and layout for accurate historical reference.
• High-quality scanning process: Scanned on an APT BookScan and converted to JPG 2000 format, which maintains legibility across pages and reproduces fine ink and paper details.
• Includes marginalia and markings: Retains notes and notations present in the source volume, useful for researchers interested in provenance and reader interaction.
• Accessible academic source: Part of the Cornell University Library print collections, giving confidence in the item's bibliographic authenticity and archival value.
• Compact single-volume format: Offers a focused memoir that fits easily into a historian's personal library or a course reading list without extraneous commentary.

Who It's For

This edition will appeal to Civil War enthusiasts, maritime historians, and graduate students seeking primary-source material on United States naval operations. The preserved marginalia makes it particularly useful to archival researchers and those studying reception history or the book as an artifact.

Readers who prefer modern annotated editions, contemporary introductions, or clean reprints without original markings may want to look elsewhere; this reproduction is faithful to the scanned copy and does not add modern editorial apparatus.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Faithful reproduction of the original 1917 volume preserves authentic pagination and layout.
• High-quality APT BookScan conversion and JPG 2000 format retain page detail and clarity.
• Includes original marginalia and notations, adding research value for provenance studies.

Cons

• Contains the original volume's marks and marginalia, which some readers may find distracting rather than helpful.

Specifications

Our Verdict

This reproduction is recommended for scholars and collectors who need an authentic facsimile of the 1917 memoir with all original markings intact. It represents good value as an archival-quality scan that preserves the physical evidence of the original reader experience, though casual readers seeking a cleaned-up text should consider a modern annotated edition instead.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this edition include modern annotations?
No. This reproduction is a direct scan of the 1917 volume and does not add modern editorial notes or commentary.

Are the marginalia and marks included?
Yes. All marks, notations, and marginalia present in the original library copy are retained in the scan.

Who performed the scanning?
The volume was scanned on an APT BookScan and converted to JPG 2000 format by Kirtas Technologies for the Cornell University Library.