Robelle 24 ft Ultimate Charcoal Winter Pool Cover - Solid Protection

In this review we look at the Robelle 24 ft Ultimate Charcoal Winter Pool Cover and why it works for pool owners who want a heavy-duty, solid winter cover that resists snow and ice. The cover is designed for 24 ft round above ground pools but includes a full 4 ft overlap so installation is easier and the cover can float loosely on the water. The biggest reason to buy is durability: at 5.2 oz/yd2 with a 14 x 14 scrim and a 20-year warranty, this cover prioritizes long-term protection over the offseason.

Key Features

• Extra overlap: A 4 ft overlap (28 ft total material) simplifies installation and helps the cover stay secure over rails or decks when used with water weights.
• Solid construction: The solid polyethylene top prevents water from passing through, keeping leaves and debris out of the pool during winter.
• Heavy material: The 5.2 oz/yd2 material and 14 x 14 scrim provide strength and tear resistance compared with lighter covers.
• Complete installation kit: Includes a winch and cable to secure the cover through grommets for better performance in high-wind areas.
• Winter protection: Designed to withstand snow and ice, helping to protect the pool structure and reduce maintenance in spring.

Who It's For

The Robelle 24 ft Ultimate winter cover is best for above ground pool owners who want a long-lasting, solid cover that keeps out all water and debris and who value an industry-leading warranty. It suits those with decks who can use vinyl water weights or run the cable under a partial deck to fasten the cover securely.

Owners looking for an inexpensive seasonal tarp or a mesh cover that allows rainwater through should look elsewhere. Also, swimmers with atypically large top rails may prefer ordering the next pool size up so the cover floats loosely and avoids tension at the grommets.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• High material weight and 14 x 14 scrim deliver notable strength and expected longevity.
• Four foot overlap plus included winch and cable make installation straightforward compared with narrower covers.
• Solid design blocks water and debris, beneficial for regions with heavy snow or leaves.

Cons

• Some customers report the material feels thin compared with expectations, so perceived thickness can vary.

Specifications

Brand	Robelle
Designed pool size	24 ft round above ground
Cover size (with overlap)	28 ft
Material weight	5.2 oz/yd2
Scrim	14 x 14
Style / model	5124-4
Warranty	20-Year Warranty

Our Verdict

The Robelle 24 ft Ultimate Charcoal Winter Pool Cover is a good choice for above ground pool owners who want a solid, heavy-duty winter cover with extra overlap and an included winch for safer installation. Its heavy scrim, solid barrier design, and 20-year warranty make it a practical value for those prioritizing seasonal protection against snow, ice, and debris.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will this cover fit pools with a deck?
Yes; install the cover on top of the deck and use vinyl water weights on top of the cover or run the winch cable around the perimeter and under the deck when possible.

Does water pass through this cover?
No, this is a solid winter cover designed to block water and debris from passing through the material.

Is an ice equalizer included?
No, the ice equalizer pillow is sold separately; the cover includes the winch and cable but not the pillow.