Rothy's The Square Mary Jane Square-Toe Flats - Comfortable

In this review of Rothy's The Square Mary Jane, the bottom line is simple: these are a comfortable, polished flat for someone who wants an easy, machine-washable slip-on that works from office to weekend. The single biggest reason to buy is the combination of a soft, plush footbed with Rothy's signature knit made from 100% recycled plastic bottles, which makes the shoe both comfortable and sustainably minded. Fit is reported as true to size overall, though a few wearers find the toe box narrower than expected.

Key Features

• Exceptional comfort: A soft, plush footbed and cushioned insoles provide daylong comfort for walking and standing.
• Refined square-toe style: The squared toe gives a polished, modern silhouette that dresses easily from work to evening.
• Better materials: The knit upper is made from Rothy's signature thread sourced from 100% recycled plastic bottles for a more sustainable choice.
• Machine washable: Insoles and shoes can be removed and washed on cold, making care straightforward and extending wear life.
• Durable construction: Comfortable insoles sit on durable outsoles that handle daily wear without feeling flimsy.
• True-to-size fit tip: Rothy's recommends the Square fits true to size, simplifying ordering for most shoppers.

Who It's For

These flats are best for someone seeking an everyday shoe that balances comfort with a neat, work-ready look. They suit commuters and professionals who need a versatile pair that transitions from meetings to after-work plans, and who value washable shoes and recycled materials.

Those who prefer very wide toe boxes or need pronounced arch correction should try them on first or consider a different style, since some customers describe the fit as a touch narrow. If you require heavy-duty hiking or athletic performance, these are not the right choice.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Soft cushioning and plush footbed make walking and standing comfortable.
• Polished square-toe design works with business casual and dressier outfits.
• Machine washable construction makes maintenance easy and practical.
• Made from recycled plastic bottles, produced in a LEED and zero-waste factory.

Cons

• Some wearers find the toe area narrower than expected, so those with wide feet may need a larger size or alternate style.

Specifications

Style	The Square Mary Jane, square-toe slip-on flat
Material	Knit thread from 100% recycled plastic bottles
Comfort	Soft plush footbed with cushioned insoles
Care	Machine washable; remove insoles and wash on cold, air dry
Manufacturing	Made in Rothy's LEED and TRUE Zero Waste factory
Fit	Fits true to size (fit tip noted)

Our Verdict

Rothy's The Square Mary Jane is a smart pick for shoppers who want a comfortable, sustainable flat that cleans easily and looks refined. It delivers reliable cushioning and a tidy silhouette for office and casual wear, making it a good value for buyers who prioritize comfort and low-maintenance care. Try them on if you have a wider forefoot, but otherwise they are a versatile everyday option.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these shoes washable?
Yes. Remove the insoles, wash shoes and insoles on cold with mild detergent, and air dry; do not use heat.

Do they run true to size?
Rothy's states The Square fits true to size, though a minority of customers find the toe box a bit narrow.

What are they made from?
The knit thread is made from 100% recycled plastic bottles and the shoes are produced in a LEED and TRUE Zero Waste factory.