Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Super Soft Timothy Hay - For Fussy Eaters
Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Super Soft Timothy Hay - For Fussy Eaters
Price subject to change. Tap below for current.
Couldn't load pickup availability
In this review of Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Super Soft Timothy Hay the bottom line is simple: this 20 lb bale is best for owners of guinea pigs, rabbits, and other small animals who need an extra-soft, highly palatable grass hay. The single biggest reason to buy is the hay's unusually soft, leafy texture, which helps entice fussy eaters and animals with mouth pain to chew more hay. The review finds the hay generally fresh and high in usable nutrients while acknowledging some variation in color and that not every pet will accept it immediately.
Key Features
- Super Soft Texture: The third cutting is harvested later and processed to minimize stem and seed head so even animals with sensitive mouths can eat comfortably.
- High in Protein and Fat: This hay provides a bit more energy and nutrient density than earlier cuttings, useful for small animals needing to gain weight.
- Leafy and Fresh: The product is sold as 100% fresh and tends to be leafy, which increases acceptability for picky eaters.
- Suitable for Oral Sensitivities: The soft composition makes it a practical option for animals suffering from mouth pain or dental issues.
- Satisfaction Guarantee: Backed by a 100% satisfaction guarantee, offering reassurance if the pet will not eat the hay.
Who It's For
This hay is ideal for owners of guinea pigs, rabbits, and other small animals that are selective or have dental discomfort; the soft, leafy texture helps encourage chewing and increases fiber intake. It also suits small animals that need to gain a bit of weight because the slightly higher protein and fat can help support body condition under careful feeding.
Those who should look elsewhere include owners who want very coarse, stemmy hay for continuous gnawing enrichment or those on a strict budget who find large bales less economical for occasional use. Also, pets that consistently refuse new hay varieties may not accept this cutting despite its softness.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Soft, leafy texture encourages eating from fussy animals and pets with mouth pain.
- Higher protein and fat content can assist animals needing to gain or maintain weight.
- Customers commonly report good freshness and hay quality on arrival.
- Large 20 lb bale reduces the need for frequent repurchasing for multi-pet households.
Cons
- Color and perceived value vary among customers; some report greener hay while others see browner bales.
- Not every individual pet will accept the cutting, so acceptance can be mixed.
Specifications
| Product Name | 3rd Cutting Super Soft Timothy Hay |
| Weight | 20 lb |
| Cutting | Third cutting (late summer/early fall harvest) |
| Texture | Super soft, leafy with minimal stem |
| Nutritional Notes | Higher in protein and fat compared with earlier cuttings |
| Freshness | Sold as 100% fresh |
| Satisfaction | 100% satisfaction guarantee |
Our Verdict
Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Super Soft Timothy Hay is a sensible buy for owners of guinea pigs and rabbits who need a soft, appetizing hay to encourage eating or to help with weight recovery. Its leafy softness and higher nutrient density make it good value for multi-pet households, though individual pet acceptance and color may vary.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is this hay suitable for rabbits with mouth pain?
Yes, the super soft, low-stem composition is designed to be easier to chew and is suitable for animals with oral sensitivity.
How large is the bale and will it last?
The product comes as a 20 lb bale; how long it lasts depends on the number and size of pets but it is generally convenient for multi-pet homes.
Will every pet accept this hay?
No, acceptance varies: many pets prefer the soft, leafy texture, but some animals are selective and may refuse it initially.
Editor's Take
Small Pet Select 3rd Cutting Super Soft Timothy Hay is ideal for guinea pigs and rabbits needing a soft, leafy hay to encourage eating or aid weight gain; freshness and nutrient density make it a good value, though acceptance and color can vary.

Recently viewed
Recently viewed products will appear here as customers browse the store.