Try Them All + Extra Butter Me Up - Family Sized 6 Pack

In this review of the Try Them All + Extra Butter Me Up family sized 6 pack, the bottom line is simple: this offering is for families and snack lovers who want a variety of hand-popped popcorn made with real ingredients. The reviewer found the mix most notable for its clear, buttery flavor and small-batch, hand-seasoned approach, which gives each bag a more handcrafted taste than mass-produced alternatives. If you prioritize quality of flavor, non-GMO and gluten-free handling, and a recyclable bag program, this pack delivers a compelling reason to try it.

Key Features

• Small-batch popping: Each bag is popped and seasoned by hand, which preserves a fresher, more carefully balanced texture and seasoning profile than large-scale production lines.
• Real ingredients: The Extra Butter Me Up variety uses real butter and cheddar ingredients, giving the popcorn an authentic dairy-forward flavor rather than artificial butter notes.
• Gluten-free and non-GMO facility: The Popzup Popcorn Factory operates as a dedicated gluten-free and non-GMO facility, a clear benefit for people with sensitivities and those avoiding GMOs.
• Recycling program: The Win-Win Free Popcorn recycling program lets customers return bags for recycling, which reduces waste compared with single-use packaging options.
• Family-sized convenience: The 6 pack supplies multiple servings for households, parties, or repeated snacks, making it easy to share or store extra bags for later.

Who It's For

This pack is best for households that want a quick, shareable snack with an emphasis on real ingredients and careful, small-batch preparation. Families, snack-curious buyers, and those who value a dedicated gluten-free production facility will appreciate the attention to ingredient sourcing and the buttery flavor profile.

Shoppers looking for the lowest possible price per ounce or those who expect consistently peak-day freshness from long supply chains should look elsewhere; a few customers note mixed freshness impressions and some consider the product pricier than mainstream mass-produced popcorns.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Buttery, well-rounded flavor from real butter and cheddar ingredients delivers an authentic snack experience.
• Small-batch, hand-seasoned production can mean better texture and more consistent seasoning on each bag.
• Dedicated gluten-free and non-GMO facility reduces cross-contact concerns for sensitive consumers.
• Recycling program offers an environmentally mindful way to return packaging.

Cons

• Some buyers report mixed freshness; not every bag arrives with the same level of crispness expected.
• A number of customers consider the price higher than comparable snack options, affecting perceived value for money.

Specifications

Product name	Try Them All + Extra Butter Me Up - Family Sized - 6 Pack
Brand	Popzup
Production	Popped and seasoned by hand in small batch
Facility claims	Dedicated gluten-free & non-GMO facility
Key ingredients	Real butter and real cheddar
Special program	Win-Win Free Popcorn recycling program (details on bag)
Company	Family owned in Somersworth, New Hampshire

Our Verdict

For anyone who values authentic buttery flavor, small-batch attention, and a gluten-free, non-GMO production environment, this 6 pack is a solid choice that tastes more handcrafted than typical snack aisle popcorn. It is best for families and giftable snack boxes, though price-conscious buyers or those who demand absolute peak freshness every time may find better value elsewhere.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this popcorn gluten-free?
Yes. Popzup is produced in a dedicated gluten-free facility, making it suitable for those avoiding gluten.

Does the product use real butter?
Yes. The Extra Butter Me Up flavor is made with real butter and real cheddar ingredients for an authentic taste.

Can I recycle the packaging?
Popzup runs a Win-Win Free Popcorn recycling program; return details are printed on the bag for customers who want to participate.