Whirlpool W10873791 SxS Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly - Reliable

In this review of the Whirlpool W10873791 OEM SxS Refrigerator Ice Maker Assembly, the bottom line is simple: it is a direct, genuine replacement for several side-by-side refrigerator models and is best for DIYers who need a precise fit and straightforward swap. The reviewer found that the ice maker reproduces the original function, includes the full housing and assembly, and installs with basic hand tools when the refrigerator power and water are safely turned off. While some buyers reported mixed longevity, the one year warranty and OEM construction make it a sensible first choice when originality and compatibility matter.

Key Features

• Genuine OEM: Built to Whirlpool engineering standards, the assembly matches factory fit and function so it integrates cleanly with compatible refrigerators.
• Complete 10-cube assembly: Includes the housing and full ice maker unit so you replace the entire mechanism rather than patching parts.
• Model compatibility: Made to work with specific models such as WRS571CIHZ, WRS588FIHZ and KRSC703HPS, reducing fitment guesswork for side-by-side refrigerators.
• Replacement part coverage: Replaces several earlier part numbers, simplifying identification if your original number is one of the listed replacements.
• One year warranty: Backed by a one year warranty that covers defects, offering some protection against early failures.
• Serviceable installation: Designed for replacement with common hand tools and basic disassembly, making it accessible to homeowners with novice repair experience.

Who It's For

This ice maker assembly is best for owners of compatible Whirlpool and related side-by-side refrigerators who want a factory-correct replacement. It suits DIYers comfortable unplugging the appliance, shutting off the water, and handling modest disassembly to remove the old ice maker and reuse the existing bail arm.

Those who should look elsewhere include users with very old or noncompatible models, or anyone who prefers a long-term aftermarket upgrade with extended warranty claims history; some customers have reported failures under a year, so commercial users or those seeking maximum longevity may consider alternative solutions or professional repair options.

Pros & Cons

Pros

• Factory-engineered fit and function makes installation predictable and reduces fitment errors.
• Complete 10-cube assembly simplifies replacement by providing the housing and mechanism together.
• Good value and straightforward installation for homeowners with basic tools and novice repair experience.

Cons

• Some customers reported durability issues within months, so long-term reliability can be mixed.
• Does not include a bail arm, which must be retained from the original unit.

Specifications

Our Verdict

The Whirlpool W10873791 is a practical OEM replacement for side-by-side refrigerators that need a direct swap. It delivers correct fit and function, is easy to install for a homeowner with basic skills, and is cost effective given the included housing and warranty. Buyers seeking the most reliable long-term performance should weigh mixed durability reports but for most compatible refrigerators this is a sensible first choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this assembly include the bail arm?
No. The assembly does not include a bail arm; you must remove and reuse the bail arm from the existing ice maker.

Which models is this compatible with?
The part is compatible with models such as WRS571CIHZ, WRS588FIHZ, WRS555SIHZ, KRSC703HPS, and WRS588FIHV.

Is installation difficult?
Installation requires basic hand tools, unplugging the refrigerator, and turning off the water supply; it is suitable for a homeowner with novice repair experience.